Beyond the Headlines: 5 Surprising Things the Bank of Canada's Latest Rate Hold Reveals

https://bradchisling.exprealty.com/ask/d6b4118d21dc957e8072bb12578a409e

Register for our deep dive AI podcast

Don't be fooled by the Bank of Canada's decision to do nothing. While the headline read "policy rate held at 2.25%," the real story lies beneath the surfac a high-stakes drama where surprising economic resilience is clashing with immense structural challenges.

To understand where Canada’s economy is really headed, you have to look past the Bank’s deliberate calm. Here are five key takeaways from the decision and what top economists are saying about the road ahead.

1. The Rate Cuts Are Over, and a Hike Could Be Next

It might seem counter-intuitive, especially since the Bank of Canada cut its policy rate in both September and October of 2024. However, the expert consensus is clear: the rate-cutting cycle is finished. In a surprising turn, economists now believe the next move from the central bank is more likely to be a hike than another cut.

RBC Economics has shifted its outlook, noting that the risks of interest rate hikes before the end of 2026 "have been edging higher." Their analysis suggests a firm end to the easing that characterized the latter half of 2024.

"...we think the BoC is done with rate cuts, and that the next change in interest rates is more likely to be a hike..."

This represents a significant and rapid pivot in the economic outlook, signalling that the conditions that prompted the recent cuts may already be fading.

2. The Canadian Economy Is Proving Far More Resilient Than Expected

Despite persistent headwinds from US trade protectionism, the Canadian economy is demonstrating remarkable strength. The Bank of Canada's own press release highlighted a "surprisingly strong 2.6%" GDP growth in the third quarter. This resilience has become a central theme in the Bank's communications.

Governor Tiff Macklem captured this sentiment perfectly, underscoring the shift in the economic narrative from recession fears to surprising robustness.

"...at the end of the year, as we get to the end of the year, the R word people are talking about is resilience."

This unexpected strength, partly explained by upward revisions to past economic data, provides the crucial context for the Bank’s pause. In fact, this surprising economic strength is exactly why some analysts believe the Bank is now behind the curve, with a policy rate that may be too low for current conditions.

3. The Current Interest Rate Might Actually Be Too Low

Here’s a fascinating insight: according to some economic models, the Bank of Canada may be keeping interest rates lower than current economic conditions actually justify. An analysis by Scotiabank Economics using the Taylor Rule—a formula used to guide policy rate decisions—suggests the Bank’s recent cuts were more of an "insurance" policy against future risks than a reaction to today's data.

The very inputs that make the model flash red—like the "surprisingly strong 2.6% GDP growth" and the upward revisions to past economic data—reinforce this logic. The report suggests that the central bank is acting pre-emptively, providing stimulus to guard against potential future downturns rather than setting rates based purely on present performance.

"This combination shows the policy rate is presently around 25–50bps too low."

This reveals that the Bank of Canada is playing a long game, carefully balancing the economy's current strength against the significant uncertainty that still lies ahead.

4. Why the Bank of Canada Isn't Celebrating a Strong Jobs Report

Recent labour market data has been undeniably positive. The Bank’s own statement noted that employment has shown "solid gains" over the past three months and that the unemployment rate fell to 6.5% in November.

Yet, in the very same announcement, the Bank tempers the good news. It refers to the data as just "some signs of improvement" and immediately points out that "economy-wide hiring intentions continue to be subdued." This careful, balanced language reveals a central bank deliberately looking past short-term wins to focus on underlying weakness.

Governor Macklem reinforced this tempered view at the press conference.

"You're seeing overall employment has moved up. So that is encouraging. There is some resilience to the economy. What I would say, though, is looking forward, it hasn't fundamentally changed our view."

This demonstrates how a central bank looks past encouraging monthly figures to identify deeper, more stable trends before making significant shifts in policy.

5. Inflation Is a Tug-of-War Between Two Giant Forces

The Bank of Canada sees inflation as being caught in a tug-of-war between two powerful and opposing economic forces.

On one side, upward pressure on prices is coming from the "cost pressures associated with the reconfiguration of trade." As Governor Macklem explains, ongoing trade friction with the United States makes the Canadian economy operate "less efficiently, with higher costs," which pushes inflation higher.

On the other side, downward pressure is being applied by "ongoing economic slack." This means the economy still has excess capacity—it can produce more goods and services than are currently being demanded, which forces businesses to compete on price and keeps inflation down. For now, the Bank believes these two forces will "roughly offset" each other, keeping inflation near the 2% target.

However, private sector economists are flagging this as a key risk. RBC Economics offers a sharp counterpoint, arguing that the Bank's benign outlook may be too optimistic. On both the trade cost and economic slack fronts, their report warns, "we see risks mostly tilted towards more inflationary pressures, not less."

This tension highlights the profound and structural nature of the challenge, which the Governor himself acknowledged.

"Increased trade friction with the United States means our economy works less efficiently, with higher costs and less income. This is more than a cyclical downturn—it’s a structural transition."

Conclusion: A Delicate Balance

The simple headline of a rate hold masks a complex and tense economic reality. The Bank of Canada is navigating a major structural adjustment, balancing a surprisingly resilient domestic economy against persistent global trade friction. The decision to hold the rate is not a sign of inactivity, but a deliberate pause in a highly uncertain environment.

The Bank of Canada is betting that economic slack can contain the inflationary pressures from a structural trade shock. But with a resilient economy and a policy rate that may already be too low, the crucial question for 2026 is whether the Bank is providing prudent insurance or simply falling behind a curve that is steepening faster than anyone expected.